tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-93886340617240869.post3804479470824912407..comments2023-05-03T18:47:04.116+03:00Comments on פורום לנושאי סת"ם: יו"ד עם רגל ארוכהmoshe weinerhttp://www.blogger.com/profile/17623258731013647342noreply@blogger.comBlogger3125tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-93886340617240869.post-59683027849055526202012-05-17T07:43:32.396+03:002012-05-17T07:43:32.396+03:00OK given there is some borderline, albeit undefine...OK given there is some borderline, albeit undefined [in siman 36 in exact measure], the chidush of the Maharshag is that although the yud crossed this borderline, the unique way the foot is shaped, makes its a kosher yud.<br /><br />I totaly disagree with the concept. Once a letter passed its shiyur - either to long as a vav 5 kulmusim long, or to short as a hai that its left foot is less than a mloi ois ketana, although both cases a tinok will recognize the letter because of its unique form, it is pasul - because the measure is incorrect.<br /><br />The same applies to a yud !<br /><br />This is the way I understand the Mordechai and SA Harav quoted.moshe weinerhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/17623258731013647342noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-93886340617240869.post-80544992254038339722012-05-16T21:42:09.187+03:002012-05-16T21:42:09.187+03:00Of course there is certainly a border for how long...Of course there is certainly a border for how long one can still ask a tinok, certainly if it is too long it is automatically posul and no point to ask a tinok. <br />The chidush of the Shut Mharsha"g vol 1 siman hei is that even if it is very long and enough to be a vuv but since it is curved one can rely on krias hatinok.<br />Not clear if SA HaRav ibid would go that far but still lichora more lenient than what comes out from the above.Dovid Nissan Bressmanhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/10438738086223919397noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-93886340617240869.post-28772021196510993332012-05-16T21:32:00.159+03:002012-05-16T21:32:00.159+03:00Thank you for this, however still the SA HaRav 36:...Thank you for this, however still the SA HaRav 36: Ois yud and Mishnas Sofrim ois yud write not to lengthen the regel of the yud "shelo tidameh livuv vtipasel ol yedai krias Hatinok"<br />Shows that if it is long one must ask a tinok (not necessarily automatically posul)Dovid Nissan Bressmanhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/10438738086223919397noreply@blogger.com